Hey everyone, how's it going? I'm doing pretty well for a Thursday. Happy SNW Premiere Day to all of my fellow Trekkies who are reading this. In honour of the season 4 premiere of Star Trek: Strange New Worlds, which is today, I decided to review a Star Trek comic. Specifically the first issue of Star Trek: Starfleet Academy - Lost Contact, which is a mini-series based on the Starfleet Academy TV series that came out with its first season earlier this year. There will be a few spoilers in this review because it is a single issue out of however many the series is supposed to be, and I can't talk about anything if I don't include some spoilers. Let's get into it.
The cadets of both Starfleet Academy and the War College are on a training exercise with their ship/Starfleet Academy's central building, the USS Athena, which is on a planet that is supposedly abandoned. Genesis, Caleb, Tarima, Jay-Den and Kyle were chosen for the exercise so SAM and Darem Reymi don't appear in this issue, neither does Tarima's brother, Ocam. I don't know if they appear in the following two issues that have come out so far, but they aren't in this one. However, something goes wrong and the cadets end up being stranded on the planet, cut off from the Athena, so now the cadets have to learn how to survive on this supposedly abandoned planet, while overcoming their usual trials and tribulations, namely Genesis's need to lead even in situations where she really shouldn't be the leader, or wasn't chosen to be the leader to begin with. I'll talk about that a bit more later.
It was really interesting to see Kelrec, Nahla Ake, and the cadets in comic book form. It was cool though. Corali Espuna is the artist on this book and they do a really good job. Nora Serrano is the colorist. My favourite panel in this issue is at the beginning when Kelrec and Ake are briefing the cadets and the panel is a shot of Ake and she's rolling her eyes at Kelrec, as she has a habit of doing whenever he says something stupid, which is a lot. That's it. That's the panel. Eye rolling isn't something I've ever seen captured in a comic book before. Not even a Star Trek comic. So I just thought that Espuna and Serrano captured it so well in that one panel.
Based on the Stardate at the beginning of this issue (Stardate 869013.5), the miniseries takes place between episode 7, "Ko'Zeine", which doesn't have a Stardate attached to it, and episode 8, "The Life of the Stars" (Stardate 869372.1). Which makes sense given Genesis's attitude in this issue. Though, if I'm being honest, she's very close minded and unreasonable when it comes to listening to her fellow cadets. Even more than the show portrayed her as. Especially because Jay-Den and Caleb were making very good suggestions for their situation, but Genesis is like, "we're gonna do the opposite of that". For no other reason than "I'm an admiral's daughter, and this will look good on my transcript when I graduate in four years". Which completely ignores the empathy and willingness to listen to others that she gained in episode 3 following the war games simulation debacle she and Darem butted heads during that episode.
I really didn't like Genesis in this issue for that reason. I don't know if this is an example of the comic book writer, Layne Morgan, not being able to see episodes of the show before writing the comic, or if the writer simply chose to write Genesis as a more hotheaded individual than she was portrayed as in the show. Not knowing the production history of this comic in particular, I can't say for certain.
However, given my knowledge of the history of comics based on Star Trek, particularly the original Gold Key series, which was published during the time the original show was on the air in the late '60s, and the first comic book miniseries that DC published based on TNG in 1988, chances are pretty good that the writer of this book had to have it written before the show started coming out, so they weren't able to watch it beforehand. That's how it feels to me anyway. Like the writer was only able to look at the character descriptions for the cadets and wrote them based off of those descriptions rather than based off of how the actors and actresses portrayed them in the show.
Overall, this was a good issue, but it's very much a setup issue. It's also not a comic I would hand to someone who hasn't watched Starfleet Academy just because it does little to set up the characters overall, and simply, and quickly, just sets them up for this particular story. I would recommend it if you've already seen the show, love the show, and need to spend time with these characters again before season 2 starts sometime next year.
Alright my friends that's it for me for today. I'll be back on Saturday for my review of the season premiere of season 4 of Star Trek: Strange New Worlds as I'm recording it on cable when the episodes air tonight, so I can watch them tomorrow night. So, no Rental Recommendations this week over on My Nostalgia Blog. Until then have a great rest of the day and I will talk to you all later. Take care.


.jpg)
.jpg)



.jpg)


.jpg)